Employee Benefits Consulting Firm

Providing Strategic Planning, Professional Services, and Technology-based Solutions Since 2000.

Island Group Plans

Our Firm

Island Group Plans is an employee benefits insurance firm offering strategic planning and customized technology-based solutions to businesses in New York Metro and the East Coast region.

We believe it’s not just about choosing a plan, but it’s a pivotal business decision.

We commit to deliver white-glove service, leading technology, and compliance updates to our clients. Get in touch with us and know how we can help you; call (631) 588-8100 or send an email to info@islandgroupplans.com.

Core Values

Our core business values include integrity, industry leadership, and excellence. We ensure unrivaled customer and employee satisfaction with our value-added services. We help our customers find answers, implement solutions and anticipate consequences.


93% of Employers Want Access to Hr Tools & Services


Only 43% of Brokers Offer These Tools


We Offer Them at No Charge to 100% of Our Clients

Our Partners


"We've been working with Island Group Plans for years. They have handled my health & disability insurance coverage for all my employees. Their qualified staff is very knowledgeable, efficient and courteous. Island Group Plans always gets the job done right the first time. They are the perfect broker for us!" 

Linda Langley

Cactus Salons

"Island Group Plans has offered outstanding service to Pennysaver for the last 8 years. They take the time to understand our company's needs and always come up with creative, cost-saving ideas. As an HR Director who wears many hats, their dedicated employees who are focused on my company, lighten my benefit administration load all year long. Thank you Island Group Plans!" 

Mary Locascio

All Island Media / Pennysaver

"It's been a pleasure working with Island Group Plans. Each year our open enrollment runs smoothly thanks to the efficient and professional staff. When our employees have questions, I have one phone call to make and it is taken care of. We value the personal connection we have with them."

Eileen Gerard

South Shore Home Health Services, Inc.

"I’ve been working with Island Group for the past 10 years and my experience has been nothing shy of awesome!  Ken Dunne & Ken Prechtl are always a step ahead of the ever changing climate of the insurance world.  Before we have time to sweat any upcoming changes, they’re already offering solutions to whatever challenges we’re faced with.  They have the nicest staff working with them.  Everyone is so kind, willing to help and knowledgeable.  Rose Whelan in particular has always gone to bat for us whether it’s on the business level or the individual level.  If there is a challenge, she will fix it!  They are truly the best in the industry and we will always put our insurance needs in their hands."

Tracey Donehower

Pazera Cabinetry

"When you're done playing the Insurance Broker games and you're ready for the real help you need, then Island Group Plans will be your next call. Our company was with a broker for 15 years, but as soon as we needed real help they forgot who we were. Island Group Plans is always ready to help. Most times they offer help before you even know you're going to need it. When annual renewal comes up, all of the options are provided. Each option is explained and discussed to see what's right for your group. When you have an issue with your carrier, Island Group Plans never hesitates to jump in. Island Group Plans is just a phone call away. AND THEY ALWAYS ANSWER THE PHONE!"

Sue McCahill

North American Air Charter, Inc.

"I switched brokerages back in 2019 to Island Group Plans. My experience has been outstanding thus far. IGP works to ensure my staff has access to the best insurance options while considering the company's bottom line. They saved my company over 10% on our 2021 renewal! Our previous broker never shopped our plans to find us cost savings. This was extremely beneficial to my company’s financial situation during the height of COVID19. I have dealt mostly with Rose Whelan, and she has been wonderful about keeping in touch and following up with me. Their customer service is exemplary, and they are incredibly responsive to all our questions and needs. IGP will do whatever it takes to make their clients lives easier."

Kacie Larsen, SHRM-CP

KLD Engineering, P.C.

"Our company has been with Island Group Plan for many years and we couldn’t be happier with the customer service and attention to detail.  They respond promptly to all calls and emails with accurate and detailed information.   At renewal time we receive a clear picture of all the options with details on coverage, cost and  pros/cons.  Rose our Account Manager goes above and beyond, taking on all of the hassles and stress of health insurance so we don’t have to deal with them, we’d be lost without her! "

Ronnie Kelly

Hampton Watercraft & Marine